European Game Development Unions Issue Manifesto Urging Studios to Abandon Generative AI

Unions representing game developers in the United Kingdom, Ireland, Spain, and Italy have published a manifesto calling on studios to abandon or strictly monitor the use of generative AI. The document outlines several criticisms of the technology, including its environmental impact, the use of stolen material, and the cognitive effects on both workers and employers.

The manifesto alleges that many workers are being implicitly or explicitly forced to use generative AI despite claims that the technology increases productivity. Instead, the unions cited studies suggesting the technology makes tasks more monotonous and causes professional skills to atrophy. The document also notes that the technology often performs tasks traditionally assigned to junior employees, which may eliminate job openings and stem the flow of new talent into the industry.

Labor representatives expressed concern regarding the long-term economic impact of the technology on employers. The unions accused generative AI vendors of obfuscating costs to employers in a scheme to eventually monopolize knowledge and skills. They argued that as workers train AI that begins as a cheap alternative, employers may eventually find themselves locked into more expensive contracts after the AI has replaced workers and captured institutional knowledge.

Regarding the use of human input to train AI without consent, the manifesto noted that while this section was the smallest in the document, the issue remains critical. The unions highlighted that the AI industry has previously admitted the technology cannot exist without copyright infringement.

The manifesto recommends that developers avoid generative AI whenever possible. If a developer chooses to use the technology or finds no alternative, the unions stated that companies should work with employees to define clear regulations.

While the exact percentage of developers using generative AI globally remains unclear, available data suggests high adoption rates. A Japanese survey from September found that 86% of respondents admitted to using the technology in some capacity, while an earlier survey indicated that more than half of developers believe generative AI is harming the industry.

FI Journal
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.