Australian Music Industry Rejects Proposed AI Scraping Exemption for Musicians

The Australian music industry has rejected a reported proposal that would grant musicians an exemption from AI scraping while allowing technology companies to train models on other copyrighted materials. The Australian Recording Industry Association (Aria) and the Australian Writers’ Guild stated they would not support a deal that leaves other creative sectors behind, describing the potential arrangement as a strategy to divide the creative community.

A report from the Australian Financial Review suggested the Albanese government is considering a copyright change where AI companies would purchase permits to train on Australian content, with music potentially being exempted. This model aligns with recent suggestions from AI firms, including Anthropic’s proposal for "conditional approval" and OpenAI’s suggestion of potentially paying into a fund for creators. While an unnamed source in the AI industry said they would welcome such a plan, the Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance said it would be "alarmed" by the idea.

Industry leaders Annabelle Herd, CEO of Aria, and Claire Pullen, CEO of the Australian Writers’ Guild, argued that such a scheme would be technically difficult to implement. They noted that content like films or television shows combine multiple copyrighted elements, such as video, screenwriting, and music, making it unclear how exemptions would function if only one element were protected. Pullen noted that the industry has been working with the government to find solutions since 2024, but claimed tech companies have refused to negotiate.

“I can’t see any creative workers leaving their colleagues behind,” Pullen said.

While Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has stated that artists must be compensated and that using work without payment is "theft," senior government figures have recently signaled that current copyright laws are insufficient. Industry Minister Tim Ayres and Acting Prime Minister Richard Marles both indicated that the status quo is inadequate for creative workers. Attorney General Michelle Rowland also promised the government would provide certainty and strong protections for Australian artists, with a spokesperson for the Attorney General stating that creative work is currently being used without consent or payment.

FI Journal
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.