Democrats Probe Justice Department for Alleged Bias in OpenAI Copyright Lawsuit

A group of congressional Democrats is circulating a letter to Attorney General Todd Blanche raising concerns that the Justice Department showed bias by siding with AI firms in a landmark copyright infringement lawsuit. The letter, according to an Axios report, questions the department's decision to intervene in the New York Times' case against OpenAI and Microsoft.

Representative Chellie Pingree of Maine is leading the letter, which is also signed by Representatives Becca Balint, Deborah Ross, Raja Krishnamoorthi, Judy Chu, Jared Huffman, and Ro Khanna. The lawmakers expressed alarm that the U.S. Copyright Office and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office were not consulted prior to the DOJ's September 1 filing. These agencies are legally required to provide impartial input on copyright issues.

The lawmakers noted that the DOJ's intervention is unusual because the Trump administration previously supported allowing courts to decide whether training AI on copyrighted material constitutes fair use. They argued that the lack of consultation with key agencies and the department's specific intervention "altogether raise serious questions about potential bias."

In addition to questioning the department's motives, the lawmakers noted that no career antitrust attorneys signed the September filing alongside senior DOJ officials. This differs from many other statements of interest, which are intended to reflect the official position of the entire U.S. government in private lawsuits.

The letter demands that the DOJ provide all draft statements and documents used to develop the statement of interest. It also requests that the department identify any external companies or organizations that provided legal analyses, briefing materials, or other communications related to the filing.

Lawmakers have requested answers to a set of questions regarding the DOJ's process by the end of the month. They stated the inquiry is necessary "so artists and creators can have confidence in the governmental interest in this case and assurance that the proper processes and procedures were followed in filing it."

FI Journal
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.